Log In | Register |
Video Editing (From Hackintosh to Windows 7)
by expo_marker
Permalink:   (94 comments)

The parts were originally bought for a hackintosh build (for video editing), and it was my first time putting one together. Instead of trying to figure which parts go with which, I figured I'd stay safe and simply copy the build from:


However, once I had everything up and running, I didn't like using a mac on a PC, so I switched back to Windows 7. I know I should have gotten better parts, but maybe I'll swap the parts when prices go down.

Disk setup:

  • Sandisk 240GB: OS + installed programs

  • OCZ Vertex 4 128: scratch + cache

  • WD Caviar Black 1TB: media storage

Edit: Wow. I didn't think people were actually going to look at this and comment, but just to clear things with the RAM... I'm temporarily using 16GB from my old computer and waiting for the 32GB or 64GB to go on sale.

Part List
Intel Core i7-3930K 3.2GHz 6-Core Processor
CPU Clock Rate3.2GHz
CPU Temperature While Idle-
CPU Temperature Under Load-
Gigabyte GeForce GTX 670 2GB Video Card
GPU Core Clock Rate980MHz
GPU Effective Memory Clock Rate6.01Ghz
GPU Temperature While Idle-
GPU Temperature Under Load-
When commenting on a completed build please keep your feedback polite and constructive, particularly if commenting on part choices and possible alternatives.
Log in to rate comments or to post a comment.
Sorted by:
jchamb49 [1 Build] 8 points 9 months ago



(although your gpu looks cheap compared to the rest of it) i7 SIX core? 80GB RAM? (that's how much HARD DRIVE SPACE I have on my laptop) over 500 GB in SSD's? THREE 24" monitors? those specs are just unheard of!!!

I have the perfect name for this monster: the BUTTERFLY!!!

lol jk to all of that, this is an EPIC rig!!!!

PacificNic [2 Builds] 5 points 9 months ago

I'm temporarily using 16GB from my old computer and waiting for the 32GB or 64GB to go on sale.

Just saying...

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 1 point 9 months ago

lol, thanks

[comment deleted]
comptech0408 4 points 9 months ago

12 sticks of mismatched RAM in a motherboard with only 8 slots?

PacificNic [2 Builds] 4 points 9 months ago

I'm temporarily using 16GB from my old computer and waiting for the 32GB or 64GB to go on sale.

Just saying...

comptech0408 1 point 9 months ago

Yeah, that comment wasn't there when I saw this build, but I am glad he cleared it up!

YourLocalPCNoob [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

I noticed this too... Its also odd how he bought a really high end gaming monitor yet only has a 670. I think he shouldve gotten another cheaper monitor and bought a 770 or 780.

LeMonarque [3 Builds] 19 points 9 months ago

...It's also possible that since this started out as a Hackintosh, it might not be a total gaming rig...

Main panel > 144Hz, reduces eye fatigue on the most-looked-at screen and is one of the best high refresh rate panels color-wise.

Side panels > IPS for color grading, 16:10 for productivity.

GTX 670 > an officially supported After Effects CS6 card that's $150 less than a 680 but just 5% slower. Below it, a 760 or 660 Ti has fewer CUDA cores and above it, a 770 was much more expensive.

3 SSDs and a small HDD > SSD for OS and programs, SSD for project files and media, SSD for exports, media cache, and pagefile, and small HDD for RAW footage and finished product storage that minimizes drive usage without being so low capacity that he's got a million HDDs around.

Not every computer is built for gaming. This is a classic workstation build, especially the drive and monitor setup.

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 8 points 9 months ago

Yeah, I didn't build this computer for gaming. It's mainly for video editing. I do play some games, though.

I own a Macbook Air and a Macbook Pro, both of which I enjoy using. I thought I would like using a mac on a pc, but it wasn't the same.

The side panels are definitely for color correction. My main use for them are for Lightroom, Premiere, and After Effects so far.

LeMonarque [3 Builds] 3 points 9 months ago

I wasn't aware you could run Premiere on OSX - but whatever's comfortable is what gets the job done the fastest right? Good decision following your gut on the OS.

I just find it confusing that it's not immediately noticeable that this isn't a pure gaming rig. As if the 3930K and hardcore disk config didn't give it away.

On that note, I think this is the first editing build I've seen that actually uses an efficient, purpose-made disk setup haha

EDIT: Ah I'm mixing up Final Cut with Premiere.

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

I really like the interface of the whole Adobe software on a mac, but that's just me.

noHassleTheHoff [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

How is it using a "mac on a pc" ? It is just a mac. It boots up as a mac. Its like having your Air plugged into a monitor and a mouse.. I'm not sure how you could tell?

(I just built a Hackintosh as well moving away from using Airs and MBPs)

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

The environment feels different in different ways. For one, I have three monitors, and moving windows quickly from monitor to monitor wasn't quick enough for me, even using 'Better Touch Tool' with the magic trackpad. I feel that it's more comfortable me to just use a mac on a laptop since it's just one screen. That's where it feels most comfortable for me.

Another thing that bugged me was my workflow using my mechanical keyboard. Because it's not a mac keyboard, I changed everything Ctrl and Alt keyboard to work like a Cmd using 'Better Touch Tool' (ie - Cmd+V became Ctrl+V and Alt+V), but I still didn't enjoy it.

I also did not like using excel on a mac. There's one part during my week where I have to organize e-mails on excel and quickly type messages from cell to cell, and you won't believe how much it slowed down my workflow. I thought I would overlook this minor thing, but it annoyed me so much.

noHassleTheHoff [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Interesting! I love my three monitors, it is the primary reason I got off of the Air and built something. The Air was running two but I didn't like the USB -> DVI. I switched to a mouse with the three monitors and I have the trackpad nearby if I want it. I also love my mechanical keyboard on OS X probably because I type all day.

The one thing I don't love is switching back and forth to Windows where the CTRL - ALT- CMD - OPTION thing is all mixed up between them. Since most of my time in Windows is gaming it doesn't really matter and the keyboard works great on OS X.

CarsonLudt 1 point 8 months ago

Next time you build a computer, you could try going for a budget build for a nice windows computer to just do tasks like organizing the e-mails on excel, it wouldn't have to be anything too expensive, I'm guessing. This is a very nice build with really good pictures, +1 from me!

comptech0408 2 points 9 months ago

Sorry about the RAM comment above then, that last statement wasn't there yet for me to read, so +1 from me, nice build!

ArrKayCee [1 Build] 1 point 8 months ago

On Amazon.com the only 670 you can buy new and still newly manufactures (the Asus Direct CU II mini) is $300, while the 770's are $340. So if he wanted a beefier card now he could easily get one, plus when he got the 670 it was most likely somewhere near $400 (which, if you remember, is the same price as a 770 before the price drop). I do understand not needing the extra power, but for the same price it is worth it.

LeMonarque [3 Builds] 1 point 8 months ago

It was not most likely near $400. That 670 has been available for $330 or less since the beginning of July. The price history data is right there

ArrKayCee [1 Build] 1 point 8 months ago

I was looking at getting a 670, even when the 770's had recently came out; at that time the 670 was $370. That was earlier this year.

xBlood_Monkey [9 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

It's possible that this build was finished before the 700 series came out.

xBlood_Monkey [9 Builds] 3 points 9 months ago

Very nice. More pictures would be nice, as well as pictures of your whole setup. :)

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Just got some pictures up!

xBlood_Monkey [9 Builds] 3 points 9 months ago

Very nice! :D

Zeus [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

Provide a more detailed description!

And add some more pics!!

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Sorry about that. My friend showed me this website today, and I just decided to play around and just list my build. I didn't think anyone would actually look at it.

Also, I just posted up some pictures.

alextargaryen [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

i'm confused on the ram...

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

The RAM was taken from my old computer for temporary use. I'm waiting for the 32GB or 64GB to go on sale xD

alextargaryen [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

Thank you for clarifying!

SparkyOnPC 3 points 9 months ago

link to the wallpaper???

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

I forgot where I got the wallpaper, but I'll link you to my Dropbox:


Gidbrel [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago


SparkyOnPC 2 points 9 months ago
noob_for_life 3 points 9 months ago

doesnt that little mic plugged into your keyboard pick up the sound of you typing?

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Yes, it definitely does, and more so because it's a mechanical keyboard. However, I use it for games like Dota 2 where I activate the mic manually, and at the same time, I'm not typing a message; I just hit the common q,w,e,r,a,s,d buttons.

I also use it for Skype, but then again, no one has complained about the typing noise yet.

rclai 2 points 9 months ago

I have complained about the noise, but ONLY IN MY HEAD MUHAHHAHAHAA!

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

You should get one to annoy Lindsay xD

I recommend the MX Cherry Blue mechanical keyboards

Anthony21 [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

Nice rig man, I also am running a bit of OS X Mavericks but can you help me out here?

My problem is, once i had build my build 1-2 weeks ago, I ran the setup of OS X Mavericks Installation Perfectly from a 16GB mini SD card via USB.

After it installed, it booted up showing MultiBeast after using UniBeast.

At the time, it pretty much unextracted the installation into the USB copy Multibeast with the files shown.

Anyway, when it was time to show MultiBeast again, ya supposed to tab on the Software which wasn't there before.

But after the Apple Logo, it went black making my screen Out Of Range!

I've used the prompt i think but idr and i kept getting to that screen, few days went by so i redid with the installation USB and now I am getting the Out OF Range when clicking the installation, why is this happening?

I'm a pc wiz but this is the 1st time I ever come up with and I'm having problems getting the installation up now.

Yesterday, I redid it but this time, instead of the files extracting from the installation, It just copied over just being one file. Anyway, once i got it up with MultiBeast, once doing the cmd tapping the installation, shows Apple and then Out of Range! on my monitor.

Can you help me with this?

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

I had the same issue before!! I restarted and reinstalled AT LEAST 15-20 times. However, I don't quite remember the exact steps I did and I don't know if your motherboard will react the same, but here's what I think I did:

At the Chimera boot screen, I always used: GraphicsEnabler=No PCIRootUID=0 npci=0x3000 cpus=1

After checking off the parts you need at Multibeast, I had to change something BEFORE shutting the computer off. This is where I had to pay close attention. For my X79 Sabertooth motherboard, I had search for folder "Extras" in the spotlight (I think it should already be on your desktop), and then open the file "Org.chameleon.Boot.plist" in TextEdit. I had to put in this command into the file:



Here's where I placed it: https://www.dropbox.com/s/oo0q4vt0cb34zvd/Org.chameleon.Boot.plist.png

Then I had to open "smbios.plist" in TextEdit and place that same command into this file: https://www.dropbox.com/s/j2vjzw000wct402/smbios.plist.png

After this point, I set up my RAID 0 configuration before shutting down the computer. In doing, I learned that the person who I followed had this "rd=uuid boot-uuid=[paste RAID identifier] npci=0x-2000" in the "org.chamleon.Boot.plist", but it was shown after his RAID 0 configuration. To make it quick, I got mine to work after I set this up, so I never tested it out by restarting the hackintosh without the RAID configuration.

So, what I think you could try at this point is go to Disk Utility and click on the drive that you created your OS on. Then hit Cmd+I. In the picture I gave you for "org.chamleon.Boot.plist" with "rd=uuid boot-uuid=[paste RAID identifier] npci=0x-2000", try replacing that key-like code with your Universal Unique Identifier code. For me, I copied and pasted the RAID Identifier. I'm not sure if that will work for you, but after putting that in, I was able to restart without any problems or having to use Unibeast.

If you want to know what I mean at the Disk Utility, you look at this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IzvhBbEXoY (go to 3:10)

Anthony21 [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

Ok I try that in a little later.

The instructions I was following is this http://www.tonymacx86.com/374-unibeast-install-os-x-mavericks-any-supported-intel-based-pc.html

At Step 4.4 getting to .5 is the issue at the moment. Here is my build http://pcpartpicker.com/b/Hoh

But when I had it working, I was stuck at Step 5.5

Which shows about 10 seconds before getting Out Of Range!

Was so dam close, When i first started doing this, first time I was installing it, at the time i was recording myself loading it from my laptop. I've reviewed what I did even thou it was abit blury and couldnt c the screen bc i was in the way typing the cmd prompt at the MultiBeast Screen and then I hit enter, worked Perfectly so I'm wondering where I went wrong with it.

But I'll try those notes that need to be change and I probably will start scratch and watch the whole video to see if I get it working by throu that setup.

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Yeah, I used that same website to install Mavericks. I just had to follow the other guy's steps as well. At both steps 4.4 and 5.5, I used: GraphicsEnabler=No PCIRootUID=0 npci=0x3000 cpus=1

If that works for you, you should be able to get to Multibeast and select your parts. After that, I did everything I explained above.

Good luck!

Anthony21 [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

while seeing what i can do, found some page to do this cmd PCIRoot=1 -x -v, that didnt work out right so i added the UID along with it, I got to the setup finnaly, problem is that I guess i cant split my Windows Drive along side with OS X Mavericks bc I cant erase it, i even deleted the partition throu windows 8.1 desktop manage, i even deleted that side throu a windows 8.1 setup via another USB drive. sees it as NTFS.

But at least I can get to the installation without any problems, bc now, after few hrs later i was getting the Apple Logo with a Do Not Enter sign above it.

wish i had the money for an SSD but saving up for the PS4, lol

Anthony21 [1 Build] 1 point 7 months ago


I'm finally up and running OSX Maverick, 2 days ago wince my os8.1 pro evualtion mode 2 hr shutdown, no longer activated, bought a 120 gb samsung pro ssd, took me about 4-7 hrs.

used the same flash drive i made since 2 months ago with no adjustment except for one time 2months ago, idr, final code i put down to 1st time access OS is "PCIRootUID=1 -x" and BANG, Setup came up. and no raid either, idk if i ever adjusted that part at all from 2 months ago to copy that key and put where ever, just "PCIRootUID=1" and then the "-x" with it.

All goto do is to make OSX to come up instead of my HDD even thou SSD is in first place to be boot up in bios.

Starlana [2 Builds] 3 points 9 months ago

I feel you on the RAM. I'm running my system on a 2 GB 1066 stick while I wait for G. Skill Sniper replacement to show up...teehee.

SpoilerAlertPT 3 points 9 months ago

Really cool build! Loving the studio monitors

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 1 point 9 months ago


Austn [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

I love the pictures' PoV and quality. +1 just for them!

You could use a bit more internal pictures though.

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Thanks! I tried taking more pictures of inside, but there really wasn't much to take a picture of. The parts that I bought weren't color-coordinated, and there were no LED's that would even make it near the borderline of aesthetic. =)

osx_ftw 2 points 9 months ago

aye, *like button

thesupergeek [3 Builds] 3 points 9 months ago

Woah, nice build, the pictures do it justice. what camera/lense did you use? i am planning on getting a dslr camera soon, leaning twords a cannon rebel t3i, but i may change my mind depending on what you are using

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Thanks! I used a Canon 70D with the Sigma 18-35mm f/1.8 lens.

Itroitnyah [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

How are you liking your KRKs? I personally have a set of Yamaha HS80M's, but I've heard great things about KRK

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

Honestly, I don't have much to compare them to. Just like you, I also heard great things about them, and they weren't over the borderline of being too expensive. That's why I decided to stay safe and just get these. I've owned the Logitech X-230 speakers before, and I thought they were great, but I decided to upgrade to something better and stumbled upon these KRK's.

They sound awesome, not too much bass and nicely equalized. I can't stand using my headphones when playing games, so I always keep my KRK's on.

xx116xx [3 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago


Mediciu5 [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

Nice. Though after all that money into the SSD, MB, CPU, etc, why skimp on the Mouse, PSU, and HDD?

(Caveat is I don't know your financial situation nor do I want to, I'm just asking out of curiosity based on my own agenda)

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

I like my mouse. I've been using the G5 for almost 10 years now, and I'm too scared to switch to another. I don't have a store to simply test out other mice. Best Buy, Staples, etc. have crappy mice on their shelves.

I actually got the PSU a while ago because the price went down at one point, and I thought it was good enough. When the time comes, I'll shoot for the AX860i.

What's wrong with the Caviar Blacks? I need a media drive to dump all my photos and videos from my DSLR. When the prices go down, I'll be shooting for four 1TB Caviar Black HDD's in RAID 10.

Kbur215 3 points 9 months ago

I don't think he was commenting on the quality of your HDD but rather the size compared to the rest of the rigs value. Also, if you're in the market for more HDD's look at the 3TB drives from your favorite companies. the 3TB are currently the price per gigabyte from almost all manufactures.

Electrospeed 2 points 9 months ago

G500s or G700s would be my recommendation.

Mediciu5 [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

Sorry, I didn't mean that you shouldn't use what you want. I was just looking at the pricing of those items compared to what you spent on the other pieces in the build and they seemed "different".

I don't think the parts are bad, just outside the norm set with the other parts in the build. Me? I use a generic MS keyboard for gaming as size-wise it fits my limited retail space so I'm not knocking you.

As far as mice, I'll recommend the corsair M65. I like the weight, exterior feel, and the "sniper" button (slows the speed down temporarily - I would imagine FPS gaming or drawing could both use a finer touch intermittently). Or the Naga if you like MMORPGs (or anything where you're typing numbers not via the num pad).

As to the hard drive, I was thinking that to be in line with your build a 3 TB HDD would have seemed more normal. Not that you even need that much space - but again just seemed out of norm for the part costs.

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Oh, I'm still waiting for the prices of the hard drives to drop. I just had a 1TB Caviar Black in my HTPC that I simply removed in order to use it as a temporary media drive. I definitely want to upgrade this and get at least four 1TB Caviar Blacks in RAID 10. =)

spencerharden 2 points 9 months ago

this does not make any sense at all

Gidbrel [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

Have you tried using mac in an virtual environment?

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Nah, I wanted the real experience on a PC. That's why I got all those parts for this build. I already own a Macbook Air and Macbook Pro. I just wanted to see what it would be like using a Mac Pro. =)

xx116xx [3 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

I love how the RAM you are waiting on is more expensive then my budget for a new computer...

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Lol, I know that's expensive. I might have to just settle for the 32GB.

fsma92 [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

how do you like the logitech g400?

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

It feels great! I've also used the G5 and MX518, both of which feel exactly the same as the G400. I used this type of mouse for about 10 years, and I have had no complaints. The G400, however, is lighter, and it doesn't have weights that you can stick it like the G5.

I don't need to mice that have tons of buttons all over. I play Dota 2, and using Alt+whichever key works great for me. =)

fsma92 [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

ok im got the g400s for 40$ I needed a comfortable mouse :p

Expo 2 points 9 months ago

How is that gigabyte keyboard. I think its the only one that has cherry red switches and blue backlight. Im about to purchase it myself

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

I love just about everything on this keyboard. I can set up media keys at the very top, and this keyboard is backlit. I definitely wanted a mechanical keyboard that has media keys, and this was the next best thing. The only thing that irks me is the volume scroll wheel -- in order to mute my volume, I press on the wheel, but you kind of have to do it slowly, otherwise you could accidentally shift the wheel up or down after pressing the wheel, which cancels your muting.

There is an MX Cherry Brown keyboard for this! I just saw it on Amazon yesterday, BUT I'm not sure if it's backlit (blue backlight, at least).

I've thought about getting the Logitech G710+, but my Gigabyte backlit keyboard is blue, which I like a lot.

Expo 2 points 9 months ago

Yea this is like the only blue backlit board with red switches(which are my favorite) Also the other gigabyte board with brown switches has a white backlit. But all in all I hope i love this keyboard.

Mediciu5 [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

So what do you use the studio monitors and m-audio for? Yes, I'm prying into your master plan for your rig.

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

Underneath my the table that my computer case is sitting on, I have my guitar pedals. I also have a mic condenser sitting off to the side, along with my guitars. I would use these to record stuff on Adobe Audition.

Mediciu5 [2 Builds] 2 points 9 months ago

Fun! Thanks for the response.

TheTekJake [1 Build] 2 points 9 months ago

I've gotta ask! How is that GTX 670 running with the triple monitors? I was going to get a 780 but I didnt think it could run 3 monitors without SLI

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 1 point 9 months ago

It runs well. I have two monitors connected via DVI and one monitor via HDMI. However, I don't use it in eyefinity mode. I tried it with my Radeon 6950's in Crossfire on my other desktop to play L4D2 and Battlefield, but I didn't like it.

On my GTX 670, I play my game on the middle monitor, and I use my other monitors to play a movies/shows and surf the web. All of my monitors run smoothly. I would have gone for two GTX 670's in SLI, but Adobe doesn't utilize more than one GPU in its programs. =\

candy [3 Builds] 1 point 9 months ago

Not enough RAM. Processor underpowered. Not enough ssds. Extremely cheap build and bad construction.

But srsly though nice build

expo_marker [Submitter] [1 Build] 3 points 9 months ago

I know. The RAM was taken from my old computer for temporary use. I'm waiting for the 32GB or 64GB to go on sale xD

ThePCguy2013 2 points 9 months ago

the i7 3930k will pwn the ass out of an fx-9590.

candy [3 Builds] 2 points 8 months ago

I was being sarcastic

[comment deleted]
JCorl 1 point 8 months ago

Looks very similar to MKBHD's Hackintosh. I have to imagine that was by design, haha. I'm currently waiting on my parts to a nearly identical build. Very nice setup!

Scoutdrago3 1 point 8 months ago

I love the build, also using "focus" on a build with LEDs always makes it better. +1 c:

athanagames 1 point 8 months ago

mkbhd anyone??

jgadian 1 point 7 months ago

Are you MKBHD?

Swainey97 1 point 7 months ago

great build wish i had it :D

Hows the BENQ monitor are the coours good and hows it perform in games since its a gaming monitor?

Zaniest 1 point 7 months ago

What's the name of the desk your using? Please answer back. :)

scorza 1 point 6 months ago

Reading comments and picturing you shoveling sticks of RAM into the computer with a shovel like a cartoon train engineer.


DasXero 1 point 4 months ago

I have that mouse, and it's the greatest mouse I've personally ever used. It's so cheap too it's awesome.

PyroFuzion 1 point 4 months ago

Very very nice build. Well done my friend.

dpandian174 1 point 3 months ago

sweet build +1

what camera did you use to take the pics??

Ninjadudewhat 1 point 3 months ago

epic build, really like the clean look. also, what's that microphone thing plugged into the keyboard?

ThePCguy2013 -3 points 9 months ago

if u want a mac, get a mac, if u want a pc, get a legit pc, not a hackintosh...

mallocunbounded [1 Build] 1 point 8 months ago

Some people want to do iphone development without having to buy a mac

BlackPanther6612 1 point 5 months ago

Some of us want OS X without having to buy a Mac, either because they are overpriced or because Apple doesn't make the hardware configuration we want.

wardoner 1 point 5 months ago

or apple is just not good