I'm digging the EVGA board, but I've only ever had them or Gigabyte. If I had to guess I'd say they're pretty equal with the MSI mobo's typically, judging from reviews. Asus tends to be a little nicer, but also have a slightly higher pricetag. Really just depends on exactly what you want. I got exactly what I wanted from my board and am satisfied!
On medium-high settings, yeah it should be solid.